Mesmay's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Yoyo vs FLLFFL]

Omg hyun

Im so happy for you dude look at all the views/ awards youve got!

This is so awesome, youve always been exceptional but this is something else, every part is really, really nice.

<3

Hyun responds:

Thanks Mesmay! Love ya buddy :D

[Pokeballs]

Be proud, tolin :3

this is great. i never thought you finished it.

inspirational, interesting theme, everything was cool

[Indestructible A]

Hm.

It was bad music quality. Didnt fit either. I dunno why you uploaded this one tbh.
The music looped too.
It just missed the mark to be totally honest.

Despite that, Schwa buddy, yours was really nice. Along with one, possibly two others

[Indestructible B]

hrm

personally i only liked one or two.
guy below me- it wasnt pivot, fool.

[Two minutes of terror EP2]

You coulda made it a lot scarier..

If you'd given him less angry speech for one.

It was nice, but yeah, not really worrying. It got less scary. I wouldve made the pauses longer, and made the initial sounds a lot quieter- it makes the user turn up the volume, meaning when the action kicks in and the sounds are on normal volume, theyll get a shock from how loud it is.

[Pico's Cool]

Damn!

you used the song i intended to use for an upcoming piece.
oh well. nice flash, a little choppy on the animation for the most of it, to be honest, but it was used effectively and efficiently. the drawing and some of the artwork was a little disappointing at times.

[Batman Began]

Hahahaha

You're gonna piss off a LOT of people with the whole Heath Ledger thing :D

MoozipanCheese responds:

Yeah I think it will. He was a great actor and I respect him, but the joke was worth it.

And Liam Neeson was better.

[Castle Repercussions - B]

Amazing...

If I remember correctly, castle was one of the animations which brought me into animating. If you can inspire people like that, dude, then you're doing awesome.

Get-lost responds:

Thanks man

[Everything by Everyone]

Hmm.

Lets see how many idiots take this personally- even though a) it wasnt directed at them, and b) its not even offensive- and thus rate this a useless review.

Anyways. The reason I took 3 off was because to me... you tried to replicate animations which were already perfect. Why replicate a cartoon when the original is already the best its gonna get? Plus, to be honest I dont particularly like that art style, at least not the way you used it- thin lines, harsh gradients... it wasnt amateur, but at the same time it didnt have a style, which really sucked the life out of the animation. The music in my opinion wasnt particularly emotive either, it didnt create the "epic" feel which I assume you wouldve been wanting to capture with an animation like this. Also, i personally felt most of it was only averagely animated, no easing and quick snappy movements.

Sure, it still deserves a seven for the length and it was fairly consistent, plus points for that. Also, animating-wise, it got a hell of a lot better closer to the end.

Dissapointing overall, though. Hopefully you'l take what I said into consideration because I think it'll help quite a bit.

[Hard Love]

That was sweet.

I really liked it. I love the emotion you put into it and I apprectiated how you animated TO the music rather than busting them separate. Especially for a song like this, that was a good choice to keep it relatively synced.

Im sure you know the faults. At times the mc (when you had him walking) overlapped the rock in the wrong sense- as in his foot was on the rock rather than on the grass- not worth a deduction though, really.